fbpx

Off the Menu

If you would like a specific flavour from our full menu that is not on our Daily Menu or is not a Feature Flavour that week, there is a minimum order of one dozen of that flavour and we require at least 3 days notice. Seasonal flavours are only available to order in their season. This offer is subject to availability as we cannot always source certain items at certain times. Please call to check availability.

Vanilla Cupcakes

Susie's Classic

Daily Menu Cupcake

vanilla cake topped w/ pink vanilla buttercream & pink sprinkles

White Chocolate Raspberry

Daily Menu Cupcake

vanilla cake swirled w/ white chocolate chips topped with raspberry buttercream & a white chocolate chunk

Blue Lagoon

vanilla cake topped w/ blue coconut buttercream & sweet flaked coconut

Boston Cream

vanilla cake w/ vanilla pudding filling topped w/ rich chocolate ganache

Tiramisu

vanilla cake w/ coffee buttercream filling topped w/ cream cheese frosting & dusted w/ cocoa

Root Beer Float

vanilla cake topped w/ root beer buttercream, a dollop of vanilla buttercream & adorned w/ a straw

Pink Lemonade

vanilla cake topped w/ pink lemonade buttercream sprinkled w/ pink & yellow sugar

Bubblegum

vanilla cake topped w/ pink bubble gum buttercream & gumballs

Doughnut Cupcakes

vanilla cake w/ a hint of nutmeg encrusted in cinnamon sugar served w/ a vanilla buttercream dipper on the side

Vanilla Milkshake

vanilla cake topped w/ vanilla milkshake buttercream & adorned w/ a straw

Razz-berry

vanilla cake topped with pure raspberry buttercream & white sprinkles

Neapolitan

marble cake topped with layers of strawberry, chocolate, and vanilla buttercreams

Strawberry Shortcake

vanilla cake swirled with fresh strawberry chunks topped with fluffy meringue buttercream

Nutella

chocolate cake topped with Nutella buttercream & drizzled with chocolate

Birthday Cake

Daily Menu Cupcake

vanilla cake topped w/ chocolate buttercream & rainbow sprinkles

Chocolate Malt

vanilla cake swirled w/ crushed malt balls topped w/ chocolate buttercream, a malt ball & adorned with a straw

Creamsicle

vanilla cake topped w/ orange & vanilla swirled buttercream & an orange jellybean

Snickerdoodle

vanilla cake topped with cinnamon buttercream & sprinkled w/ cinnamon sugar

Confetti Cake

vanilla cake swirled with rainbow sprinkles, topped with colourful vanilla buttercream & rainbow sprinkles

Key Lime Pie

vanilla cake topped w/ lime buttercream & graham cracker crumbs

PB Bomb

vanilla cake topped w/ peanut butter buttercream, a layer of chocolate & sprinkled w/ peanut butter chips

Blueberry Kiss

vanilla cake w/ a kiss of lemon topped w/ pure blueberry buttercream

Blueberry Pancake

vanilla cake swirled w/ blueberries topped w/ layers of pure maple & blueberry buttercreams

Cinnamon Bun

vanilla cake w/ a brown sugar cinnamon centre topped w/ cream cheese frosting To Die For! You may never want a real cinnamon bun again after tasting this!

Strawberry Milkshake

vanilla cake topped w/ strawberry milkshake buttercream & adorned w/ a straw

Gimme a Break

chocolate cake topped with Kit Kat buttercream & a Kit Kat chunk

Lemon Meringue

vanilla cake filled with lemon curd and topped with toasted meringue

Milky Way

marble cake filled with caramel, topped with milk chocolate ganache, drizzled with caramel

Cookies & Cream

Daily Menu Cupcake

vanilla cake swirled w/ crushed Oreos topped w/ vanilla buttercream & Oreo chunks

Strawberry Fields

vanilla cake topped w/ pure strawberry buttercream & a strawberry jellybean

PB & J

vanilla cake w/ strawberry preserves filling topped w/ peanut butter buttercream

Ice Cream Sundae

vanilla cake topped with layers of chocolate, caramel & vanilla buttercream & sprinkled w/ chopped peanuts & a cherry

Better than Butterfinger

vanilla cake topped with Crispy Crunch bar buttercream & sprinkled with crushed Crispy Crunch

Snow White

vanilla cake swirled w/ white chocolate chips & crushed vanilla cream cookies topped w/ vanilla buttercream, white chocolate chips & drizzled w/ white chocolate.

Apple Crisp

apple cake w/ a streusel topping, a layer of vanilla buttercream & more streusel sprinkled on top

Swiss Alps

vanilla cake topped w/ Toblerone candy buttercream & a chunk of Toblerone

Shirley Temple

vanilla cake topped w/ lemon-lime(Sprite)-grenadine buttercream & a cherry

Maple Bacon

vanilla cake infused w/ pure maple syrup & swirled w/ crispy bacon pieces topped w/ maple buttercream & crispy bacon “sprinkles”

Cookie Dough

vanilla cake filled with chocolate buttercream topped with a scoop of cookie dough buttercream

Chocolate Cookies & Cream

chocolate cake topped with Oreo buttercream

Vanilla Chai

vanilla cake sprinkled with chai sugar topped with chai buttercream & sprinkled with more chai sugar

Rolo

chocolate cake filled with caramel topped with rich chocolate ganache & a caramel swirl

Lemon Zinger

Daily Menu Cupcake

vanilla cake w/ lemon filling topped w/ lemon buttercream & a lemon jellybean

Dulce de Leche

Daily Menu Cupcake

vanilla cake w/ a thick caramel filling topped w/ caramel buttercream & a caramel

Lemon Coconut

Daily Menu Cupcake

vanilla cake topped w/ coconut buttercream & lemon Curd & rolled in sweet flaked coconut

Half Baked

vanilla cake w/ a chocolate chip cookie dough centre topped w/ chocolate buttercream & chocolate chips

Canadian Maple

vanilla cake topped with maple buttercream & red sprinkles

The Big Chipper

vanilla cake swirled w/ chocolate chips topped w/ layers of chocolate & vanilla buttercream & chocolate chips

Carnival

vanilla cake topped w/ cotton candy buttercream, sprinkled w/ pink & blue sugar & pink candy popcorn

Toasted Coconut

coconut cake topped with coconut buttercream & covered in toasted coconut

Revenge of the Nerds

vanilla cake swirled w/ Nerds candy topped w/ coloured vanilla buttercream & more Nerds

Mint Chip

vanilla cake swirled w/ chocolate chips topped w/ mint buttercream & mint chocolate chips

Cream Soda

vanilla cake topped w cream soda buttercream, a dollop of vanilla buttercream and adorned w/ a straw

Lemon Cream Cheese

lemon cake topped with cream cheese frosting & yellow sprinkles

Lemon Raspberry

lemon cake topped with pure raspberry buttercream & yellow sprinkles

Froot Loops

vanilla cake topped with Froot Loops flavoured buttercream & sprinkled with crushed Froot Loops

Death by Chocolate

Daily Menu Cupcake

chocolate cake topped w/ chocolate buttercream & chocolate sprinkles

Peppermint Patty

Daily Menu Cupcake

chocolate cake topped w/ green mint buttercream & a peppermint patty

Chocolate Toffee Crunch

chocolate cake swirled w/ Skor pieces topped w/ chocolate buttercream & Skor pieces

Hot Chocolate

chocolate cake topped w/ hot chocolate & marshmallow buttercream & miniature marshmallows

Smarty Pants

marble cake topped with multi coloured vanilla buttercream and Smarties

Caramallow

chocolate cake w/ a caramel centre topped caramel buttercream & mashmallow fluff

Triple Chocolate

chocolate cake studded w/ semi-sweet, milk and white chocolate chips and topped w/ chocolate buttercream and more triple chips

Chocolate Strawberry

chocolate cake topped with pure strawberry buttercream and drizzled with chocolate

Strawberry Cream Cheese

vanilla cake mixed with fresh strawberry puree topped with cream cheese frosting & pink sprinkles

Black & White

Daily Menu Cupcake

chocolate cake topped w/ vanilla buttercream & chocolate sprinkles

Caramelita

Daily Menu Cupcake

chocolate cake topped w/ caramel buttercream and a chocolate covered caramel

Mocha Java

chocolate cake topped w/ mocha (coffee-chocolate) buttercream & a chocolate covered coffee bean

Cherry Bomb

chocolate cake w/ cherry filling topped w/ chocolate buttercream & a cherry

Fluffernutter

chocolate cake w/ a fluffy marshmallow filling topped w/ peanut butter buttercream & a marshmallow

E.T. Phone Home

chocolate cake swirled w/ peanut butter chips, topped with chocolate peanut butter buttercream and E.T.’s favourite candies Reese’s Pieces

Chocolate Milkshake

chocolate cake topped w/ chocolate milkshake buttercream & adorned w/ a straw

Peanut Butter Cup

Daily Menu Cupcake

chocolate cake topped w/ peanut butter buttercream & a PB cup

Turtle

Daily Menu Cupcake

chocolate cake w/ a thick caramel filling topped w/ chocolate buttercream, a caramel & pecans

Old School

chocolate cake w/ vanilla buttercream filling topped w/ rich chocolate ganache & vanilla buttercream squiggles

S'mores

chocolate cake baked with graham cracker chunks, topped with chocolate buttercream, marshmallow fluff, a milk chocolate chunk, & sprinkled with graham crumbs

Oh Oh Henry

chocolate cake w/ an Oh Henry ® candy centre topped w/ chocolate caramel & caramel buttercreams & candied peanuts

Chocolate Cheesecake

chocolate cake topped w/ chocolate cream cheese frosting & a chocolate disc

Snowball

Daily Menu Cupcake

chocolate cake topped w/ coconut buttercream & sweet flaked coconut

Rocky Road

chocolate cake swirled w/ marshmallows, chocolate chips & walnuts topped w/ vanilla buttercream, chocolate chips & a marshmallow

Neopolitan

chocolate cake topped w/ pure strawberry buttercream & white chocolate chips

German Chocolate

chocolate cake topped w/ chocolate buttercream & a gooey caramel-coconut-pecan topping

Chocolate Obsession

chocolate cake swirled w/ chocolate chips & crushed fudge cookies topped w/ chocolate buttercream, chocolate chips & drizzled w/ more chocolate. When only chocolate will do.

Chocolate Macaroon

chocolate cake swirled w/ flaked coconut topped w/ chocolate buttercream & a chocolate macaroon

Wundercake

chocolate cake w/ a Wunderbar candy centre topped w/ layers of peanut butter and caramel buttercreams and salted peanuts

Coconut Macaroon

chocolate cake topped with toasted coconut buttercream & drizzled with chocolate

Red Velvet

vibrant red buttermilk cake w/ a hint of cocoa topped w/ cream cheese frosting & red sprinkles

Elvis

banana cake swirled w/ chocolate chips topped w/ peanut butter buttercream & a banana chip

Peanut Butter Blossom

peanut butter cake with a chocolate surprise centre topped w/ peanut butter buttercream & chocolate sprinkles

Lemon Dream

lemon cake topped w/ lemon cream cheese frosting, sprinkled w/ yellow sugar

Blueberry Cheesecake

vanilla cake topped w/ cream cheese frosting, rolled in graham cracker crumbs & topped w/ blueberry filling

Chips Ahoy

vanilla cake swirled w/ Chips Ahoy cookie chunks topped w/ vanilla chocolate chip buttercream & a Chips Ahoy chunk

Cherry Cheesecake

vanilla cake topped w/ cream cheese frosting, rolled in graham cracker crumbs & topped w/ cherry filling

What's Up Doc

carrot cake topped w/ cream cheese frosting & orange sprinkles

Curious George

banana cake topped w/ cream cheese frosting & a banana chip

Chocobutter

peanut butter cake topped w/ chocolate buttercream & peanut butter chips

Sweet & Salty

chocolate cake w/ pretzels baked in, a homemade caramel centre topped w/ peanut butter buttercream, chocolate drizzle & a chocolate covered pretzel

Almond Joy

chocolate cake topped w/ toasted coconut buttercream, dipped in chocolate & sprinkled w/ almonds

Brownie Cheesecake

chocolate cake with a cheesecake swirl topped with cream cheese frosting and brownie chunks

Banana Split

banana cake topped w/ layers of chocolate & vanilla buttercream, a cherry, & drizzled with chocolate

Funky Monkey

banana cake topped w/ chocolate buttercream & a banana chip

Candy Crusher

chocolate cake topped w/ vanilla buttercream dipped in a crushed candy assortment (M&M’s, PB Cups, Snickers, Skor, Reese’s Pieces, & Crispy Crunch)

Chocolate Salted Caramel

chocolate cake topped w/ chocolate buttercream, chewy caramel & sprinkled w/ sea salt

Doughnut Cupcake

vanilla cake encrusted in cinnamon sugar served w/ a vanilla buttercream dipper on the side

Coffee Crisp

chocolate cake with a coffee buttercream filling topped w/ Coffee Crisp buttercream & crushed Coffee Crisp bars

Caramel Apple

apple cake topped w/ caramel buttercream & drizzled with caramel

Peanut Butter Perfection

peanut butter cake topped w/ peanut butter buttercream & peanuts

Grand Slam

chocolate cake topped w/ chocolate peanut butter buttercream & pretzels, peanuts, & caramel corn

Touchdown

vanilla cake topped w/ chocolate peanut butter buttercream & pretzels, peanuts, & caramel corn

Pop Tart

vanilla cake w/ a Frosted Strawberry Pop Tart chunk baked in topped w/ glaze, rainbow sprinkles, strawberry buttercream & a Pop Tart chunk

Chocolate Cherry Cheesecake

chocolate cake topped w/ cream cheese frosting, rolled in graham cracker crumbs & topped w/ cherry filling

Pumpkin Spice

pumpkin cake topped w/ vanilla buttercream (October)

Egg Nog

vanilla cake topped w/ egg nog buttercream & sprinkled w/ nutmeg (November & December)

Luck o' the Irish

chocolate cake topped w/ Irish Cream buttercream & green sprinkles (March)

Egg Hunt

marble cake w/ a hidden Mini Egg baked in topped w/ purple vanilla buttercream & crushed Mini Eggs

Trick or Treat

marble cake w/ a Snickers bar centre topped w/ chocolate & vanilla buttercream & a slice of Snickers (October)

Candy Cane

vanilla & pink peppermint swirled cake topped w/ layers of vanilla & mint buttercream & crushed candy canes (November & December)

Chocolate Stout

chocolate cake topped w/ chocolate stout beer buttercream (March)

Cream Egg

chocolate cake w/ a homemade “Cream Egg” filling topped w/ layers of chocolate & green vanilla buttercreams & a Cream Egg

Caramel Corn

caramel cake topped w/ caramel buttercream & caramel popcorn (October)

Chocolate Dipped Strawberry

chocolate cake topped w/ real strawberry buttercream dipped in rich chocolate ganache & topped w/ a fresh strawberry (February)

What the BEEP?!?

vanilla cake topped w/ Beep (limited time only, Farmers Dairy fruit beverage) buttercream

Gingerbread

gingerbread cake topped w/ vanilla buttercream (November & December)

Shamrock Surprise

vanilla & green peppermint cake topped w/ layers of vanilla & green mint buttercream & sprinkled w/ green sugar (March)

Strawberry Pink Champagne

vanilla cake w/ chunks of fresh strawberries topped w/ pink champagne buttercream & edible white pearls (Seasonal: Valentine’s & New Year’s)